EVERYONE

[poisonapple]

if you've read the atrocity of breaking dawn, please, i urge you to go and make your disappointment known.

http://community.livejournal.com/whysofailsmeyer/7861.html

this post has a link of various websites where you can rate books. spare others from having to dish out 15$ and up on this crap and show smeyers just how you really feel.

Comments

[xnausikaax.livejournal.com]

My FB convo with a certain someone.

M:
so i'm on my THIRD read of breaking dawn
its soo good

Maria:
you're crazy

M:
why didn't you like it?

Maria:
it was so inconsistent with the stuff she developed in the other three books

M:
well the "yearning" had to end...she had to get SOMETHING in the end...and it ended well, there was a nice roundoff for the jacob thing
how would YOU Have wanted to end this?
you know that bella was going to be a vampire
they were getting married,
jacob would be in pain

Maria:
but even then she brought up a lot of stuff that basically didn't flow with what she developed in the other three books
it's not up to me to end it. i had no problem with the ending. but it seems like she made up stuff to fill in points she wanted to make instead of developing her ideas
so bella got pregnant. how? just cuz she did

M:
i think the jacob/edward/bella story was nicely rounded off
we still have to see about those old vampires challenging the volturi
and about leah i'm sure
but see every book had a new element!
altho tied in with the first one to be sure (james, then laurant then victoria)

M:
well anyway there is still midnight sun, so SOMETHING to look forward too...and then the movie
i really think at least bella, edward, carlisle, esme emmett and alice were cast well
rosalie and jasper were not that good...or james for that matter

(*-_-)